In this second installment of his film trilogy (based on J. R. R. Tolkien’s three-volume novel of the same title), Peter Jackson takes on a difficult job of filmmnking: following the characters from the now broken Fellowship of the Ring through three different storylines that still form an integrated work of art. The result isn’t quite as satisfying as The Fellowship ofthe Ring was, either in capturing Tolkien’s story or in producing a work of cinematic art, but it’s certainly good enough to be worth watching. And it’s still visible that Jackson genuinely knows and loves Tolkien’s story and his fictional world and that his goal is to retell that story in film, not to make up his own story and cash in on Tolkien’s title.

Some of Jackson’s original scenes—by no means all—seem to have been written purely for the sake of action, without sufficient concern for drama. For example, as the Rohirrim travel to their fortress at Helm’s Deep, they encounter a scouting party of orcs and (not very convincing) wolves; the result is a battle in which Aragorn is wounded and separated from the Rohirrim—but the suspense is purely physical, adding little to Aragorn’s character. It isn’t as if this storyline lacked action; the battle at Helm’s Deep takes up a quarter of the film and is full of combat. The story of Merry, Pippin. and the ents leads up to the assault on Isengard, also an impressive battle scene.

In contrast, the storyline about Frodo, Sam, and Gollum, though it has action, is primarily about character interaction. The portrayal of Gollum is brilliantly handled, bringing his inner conflict over the Ring to life; this sequence will set a new standard for the use of animated characters in live action film.

Jackson’s treatment has many points that will interest libertarians. There is the argument that the Rohirrim, faced with an aggressor, cannot simply take shelter and keep the peace, but must fight to defend themselves. There is the portrayal of Aragorn, torn between his loyalty to other men and his fear that he will be corrupted by power, like his ancestor Isildur. And there is the continuing presence of the One Ring that corrupted Isildur, eating away at both Frodo and Gollum. Jackson shows once more that he was an unexpectedly good choice to bring Tolkien’s theme, story, and vision to life.